Daily KOS silences international
activist Ben Heine for "antiSemitism"
By Tinoire (*)
.
Amazing. Watch how it was done. Ben Heine, a respected political cartoonist and well-known international activist was invited to Daily Kos this week. He made two first posts lambasting Bush which were very well received with kudos, high fives and all that: Mom Would Have Spanked George W Bush\'s Butt & Bushismsactivist Ben Heine for "antiSemitism"
By Tinoire (*)
.
At his third post, the drama started:
Within seconds, the racist war-loving megaphone lobbyists from Little Green Footballs and their Heil Lieberman counterparts on the, *cough*, Left inundated Heine’s diary with hysterical screeching and melodramatic hand-wringing about how could anyone morph a Jewish face with Hitler's. What a chorus of imbeciles. As if being Jewish is some sort of a talisman against being a dangerous fascist politician with aims and ideas sharply aligned with Hitler's.
Within minutes, KOS removed the article one the shaky grounds of copyright violation despite the original author’s permission to repost. To KOS’ credit, they left the cartoons up and did not immediately deactivate the poster’s account the way that other Left Gate-keeper, www.democraticunderground.com, does. They waited until the right-wing Israeli newspaper ArutzSheva/Israeli National News published their article to do that.
(Here is the link to the excellent article: Zionism and the creation of Israel that was yanked after the well-coordinated attack from the land-o-theft crowd.)
Bottom line. Don't like being compared to Nazis? Quit defending them and thin them from your ranks.
DesertPeace, based in Jerusalem, wrote an excellent piece called IN DEFENSE OF BENJAMIN HEINE and posted an update that his KOS account has been deactivated.
Is Avigdor Lieberman the man the megaphone crowd is outraged about when his face is morphed with Hitler’s? Spare me the hypocritical outrage. Worse than watching that chorus goosestep and Seig Heil as their heroes continue with the genocide of the Palestinians is watching how willingly the Left gate-keepers enable them.
SHAME ON sites like KOS and democraticunderground for caving in to fascist pressure and being complicit in the crimes perpetrated against the Palestinians. In a few years, you will NOT be allowed to wring your hands for a repeat performance of "We didn't know".
"In the End, we will remember not the words of our enemies, but the silence of our friends." -- Martin Luther King Jr.
.
----------------------
.
(*) Tinoire is a Peace worker based in San Francisco. She is the founder of Progressive Independent
.
--> Progressive Independent is a member-moderated leftist site created to combat the growing propaganda from the corporate-owned Republicans and New Democrats who have been selling the people down the river. The PI members have no party allegiance preferring independent thought based on issues to vacuous cheerleading.
-------------------------
For those of you who don't know who Avigdor Lieberman is, the following will give you a general idea:
- Lieberman’s idea of diplomacy with Palestinians is "At 8am we'll bomb all the commercial centers...at noon we'll bomb their gas stations...at two we'll bomb their banks....”
We risk charges of war crimes, Peres tells Cabinet - In 2003, Ha'aretz reported that Lieberman called for the 10,000 Palestinian prisoners held by Israel to be drowned in the Dead Sea and offered to provide the buses to take them there.
- A storm erupted in the Knesset plenum yesterday, following Transport Minister Avigdor Lieberman's reported proposal to provide buses to take the Palestinian prisoners that Israel releases to a place "whence they will not return."
According to another report, Lieberman said the prisoners should be drowned in the Dead Sea and he would provide the buses to take them there.
Lieberman blasted for suggesting drowning Palestinian prisoners - In May 2004, he said that 90 percent of Israel's one million Arabs would "have to find a new Arab entity" in which to live beyond Israel's borders. "They have no place here. They can take their bundles and get lost," he said.
Avigdor Lieberman: Olmert\'s newest colleague- In November 2006 Lieberman called for the execution of any Arab Members of Knesset who meet with representatives of the Palestinian government, saying, "World War II ended with the Nurenberg trials. The heads of the Nazi regime, along with their collaborators, were executed. I hope this will be the fate of the collaborators in
."<11> In response, Arab Israeli Knesset member Ahmed Tibi, demanded that "a criminal investigation be initiated against Lieberman for violating the law against incitement and racism".<12>
He called Lieberman "a very dangerous and sophisticated politician who has won his support through race hatred." Lieberman was cleared of racism charges by the Israeli Deputy State prosecutor, while admitting that the office objected to the content of his statement. Tibi strongly objected to Lieberman's ministerial appointment, describing him as "a racist and a fascist". Labour minister Ophir Pines-Paz, who resigned over Lieberman's appointment, echoed Tibi's remarks, saying that Lieberman was tainted "by racist declarations and declarations that harm the democratic character of Israel".
In 1998, Lieberman called for the flooding of Egypt by bombing the Aswan Dam in retaliation for Egyptian support for Yasser Arafat.
In 2001, as Minister of National Infrastructure, Lieberman proposed that the West Bank be divided into four cantons, with no central Palestinian government and no possibility for Palestinians to travel between the cantons. - “There is nothing undemocratic about transfer. Even in Europe millions were transferred from one place to another and it helped to bring peace...The separation, like surgery, helps healing.” - Avigdor Lieberman –
The Shrinking Space of Citizenship: Ethnocratic Politics in Israel - On February 14, 2002, the Israeli government sent several light planes to spray 12,000 dunams of crops in the southern Negev region with poisonous chemicals. The destroyed fields had been cultivated for years by Bedouin Arabs, on ancestral lands they claim as their own. The minister responsible for land management, Avigdor Lieberman, explained:
- We must stop their illegal invasion of state land by all means possible. The Bedouins have no regard for our laws; in the process we are losing the last resources of state lands. One of my main missions is to return to the power of the Land Authority in dealing with the non-Jewish threat to our lands.
The Shrinking Space of Citizenship: Ethnocratic Politics in Israel - In May 2004, for example, he told a crowd of his supporters, in Russian, that 90 per cent of the country’s Arab citizens should be expelled. “They have no place here. They can take their bundles and get lost.” His speech could have had second billing with one by Adolf Hitler at a Nuremberg Rally.
Out of the shadows: Israel\'s Minister of Strategic Threats - In May 2006, Lieberman called for the killing of Arab members of Knesset who meet with members of the Hamas-led Palestinian Authority.
Lieberman calls Arab MKs who meet with Hamas \'collaborators\'- 'At the end of the Second World War not only criminals were killed in Nuremberg but also those who collaborated with them. I hope this will be the fate of the collaborators in this house.'
We demanded in that in the basic principles it be written: All those who incite and cooperate with terror and who sit in this house – should be punished. All those who continue to freely meet with Hamas, with Hizbullah, who go to make visits in Lebanon.
“Just two days ago they declared Israel's Independence Day as Nakba day (day of disaster) and raised black flags. There is a directive on terrorism, according to which those who collaborate with it must face the law,"
http://www.ynetnews.com/articles/0,7340,L-3247068,... - In 2002, Lieberman declared, "I would not hesitate to send the Israeli army into all of Area A (the area of the West Bank ostensibly under Palestinian Authority control) for 48 hours. Destroy the foundation of all the authority's military infrastructure ... not leave one stone on another. Destroy everything." He also suggested to the Israeli cabinet that the air force systematically bomb all the commercial centers, gas stations and banks in the occupied territories (The Independent, March 7, 2002).
- His entry into the government of Prime Minister Ehud Olmert, in coalition with Kadima and Labor, marks an ominous shift in the stance of the Jewish state. As Ha'aretz put it:
"The choice of the most unrestrained and irresponsible man around for this job constitutes a strategic threat in its own right. Lieberman's lack of restraint and his unbridled tongue, comparable only to those of Iran's president, are liable to bring disaster down upon the entire region."
http://www.haaretz.com/hasen/spages/778468.html
- (snip) the Lieberman that has joined the Olmert government is something else: the leader of a strong party that is getting stronger, under a Prime Minister who is a small party functionary, with whom most of the public is fed up.
The Lieberman party is quite different from the fictitious Kadima Party and the decomposing Labor Party. It is organized on military lines, with Lieberman as its one, unquestioned leader. It has organized most of the immigrants from the former Soviet Union, and is expanding into other communities, too. It appeals to the poor and downtrodden. It resembles the Bolshevik party that Lieberman knew as a young man in the Soviet Union. (To coin a formula: Bolshevism minus Marxism equals Fascism.)
When the democratic system arouses public contempt, and when the view that "all politicians are crooks" and "the system is rotten to the core" is gaining ground, such a person is a real danger to democracy.
AN OLD maxim says that Israel can fulfill only two of its three desires: to be a Jewish state, to be a democratic state and to hold on to all of the territory between the Mediterranean and the Jordan. It can hold on to the whole territory and be democratic - but then it will not be a Jewish state. It can hold on to the territory and be Jewish - but than it will not be a democratic state. It can be a Jewish and democratic state - but then it cannot hold on to all the territory.
This has been the basis of Israeli policy from the very beginning. The main argument for Sharon's "Separation" and Olmert's "Convergence" was exactly this: that in order for Israel to remain Jewish and democratic, it must give up those parts of the occupied Palestinian territories with a dense Arab population.
The extreme Right has an answer that resembles the egg of Columbus: all three aims can indeed be attained. The solution is ethnic cleansing - the expulsion of the whole of the Arab population.
That is difficult to carry out in a democratic system. Therefore, this aim almost automatically means that there must be a "strong leader". Meaning: an overt or disguised dictatorship.
(snip)
THE MOST depressing phenomenon at this moment is the lack of public reaction.
The betrayal of the Labor Party could have been expected. Amir Peretz did indeed swear that he would never sit in a government with Lieberman, but in order to remain a minister he is quite prepared to sell his principles. No great outcry could be expected from Meretz either, after Yossi Beilin had his well publicized breakfast with Lieberman and heaped praise on him and his herrings.
But the general public does not seem shocked, either. Here and there some articles did appear, but they did not point out the existential danger threatening the Israeli republic. Even the Arab public in Israel, whose very existence is menaced by Lieberman, has not set in motion a real protest. On the 1976 "Land Day", when the Arab citizens protested against the expropriation of their land, it looked different. As it did in October 2000, when the Israeli Arab public protested against a suspected threat to the al Aqsa mosque.
What is the reason for this weak reaction, which is so like the last days of the Weimar republic?
There is a growing disdain for the democratic system. There is a general fatigue after the shocks of the last year. There is a withdrawal into private cares. For the "persons in the street", it is difficult to imagine the dangers. He and she are so used to democracy, that they cannot imagine what it means to live without it. They are sure that "It Can't Happen Here".
(snip)
Uri Avnery: Avigdor Lieberman: Lovable Man! - 10/24/06 – World silent as fascists join Israel government
In a frightening but long expected move, Israeli prime minister Ehud Olmert has brought the Yisrael Beitenu party into his coalition government. The party's leader, Avigdor Lieberman, is to be vice prime minister and, as "Minister for Strategic Threats," a key member of Israel's "security cabinet" in charge of the Iran portfolio.
Hebrew University professor Ze'ev Sternhell, a leading Israeli academic specialist on fascism and totalitarianism, was quoted by the Scotsman newspaper as terming Lieberman "perhaps the most dangerous politician in the history of the state of Israel."
(snip)
In this moral and political vacuum, it is ever more urgent to heed the call of Palestinian civil society to join the growing global campaign of boycott, divestment and sanctions.
http://peaceandjustice.org/article.php?story=20061...
.











































![new bondarowicz's_website 2008 [banner 1]](http://farm3.static.flickr.com/2208/2184895861_3fe47c84a8_m.jpg)

































































































































































































33 comments:
Ben,
Sorry to hear about the fascists at Daily Kos yanking your article. I will be posting a piece about this. Everyone needs to know what a load of crap the Daily Kos is.
Hi Ben,
wishing you a fine Easter Sun day!
The truth shall set us free!!!
And NO ONE can stop us from speaking that truth... Not Daily Kos... nor anyone else.
VENCEREMOS!
Ben -- fyi -- I never go to Kos. checked it out a while back and made up my mind quickly. too many other FANTASTIC blogs (as yours) to waste even a second over there. too political - they just spin their wheels over there. chase their tails all day. it's like huffpo - the comment section there is obnoxious.
Happy Spring
Dear Ben,
I have been busy with so much, Bush’s sponsorship of the latest wholesale slaughter of Somali women, men and children, which I have predicted will happen, and marking term papers, my own work.
sorry so hear what has been done to you at Daily kos. But my dear Ben, America's left media outlets are by large pro Zionists, with the exception of countrpunch.org, I cannot recall one major US based left leaning news media which is not pro Zionism.
Those of us who live in North America know this very well. In America and to large extent in Canada, anti-Zionists are often pushed to margins where their voices have been reduced to a muffle. But there are great heroes who are willing to paid the prize for standing up to Zionism.
Edward W Said’s Columbia office had been burnt to grounds at least more than ones. Noam Chomkys’ books are often published in Canada and members of Canada communist part, some of them well respected intellectuals were bared from entering the US for being communists during the Cold War.
And, after 9/11 many Canada intellectuals, including Margaret Atwood were denied an entry to the US and many of them actually have decided not enter the US.
The US left has been died for very long time; how else can we explain neocons special success in the US but not in Canada, are contested vigorously in the UK and are on the margins in the rest of Europe? It was Gramsci in the Prisonnote books who thoroughly diagnosed "thinness" of the cultural fortification in the US society ( read in metaphors: war of Positions) as an allegory for political dynamics in capitalist modern society.
The rest of Europe and Canada are able to fortify their cultural spheres ( civil society in the broadest terms) ways in which the US has failed to do. Do not be surprised by the crude censorship and nasty comments against you at daily kos; still I am sorry to hear that you have a subjected to such crude insults and censorship.
Peace and solidity ,
Amina
P/S. I love the work of Arthus Versluis, see if you find his work useful to our times.
Many Americans would read comments such as the one as “Anti-American”! This is one of the ways which most Americans, left, right and centre deflect criticism against US inward looking US culture. Alas!
http://www.arthurversluis.com/AntimodernismInquisition.html
Hi PTcruiser, your support is very welcome. Thank you. I look forward to reading what you will come up with.
Sincerely
Quasar, Happy Easter too! Cheers
Steve, VENCEREMOS.
Hi Jersey,
I also think that there are plenty of individual and resourceful Blogs.
The debate would be much richer at DK if they allowed all kinds of ideas.
Good to see you back Amina. I hope you do well with your daily work at university.
So now you know about this blow to freedom of expression at DK.
Thanks for your analysis about the US left and right, here is what Tinoire from Progressive Independent (http://www.progressiveindependent.com) wrote about that :
"Sites like DailyKos are gatekeepers for the left side to ensure US support for Israel's war crimes. Little Green Footballs and FreeRepublic guard the right, KOS and DemocraticUnderground guard the left."
I checked Arthus Versluis's site. This professor at Michigan State University as quite an impressive CV.
PS : CounterPunch is really an amazing site, thanks for recalling that.
Indeed,Tinoire got it right.
you will find AV work impress for he is able to make a close link between fascist thoughts of Carl Schmitt and the rise of Neocons ideology in the US.
I do agree that it is always shocking when you are confronted with such crude and blatant censorship. Funnily, the Bush people think freedom is America's gift to the rest of the world!
One more URL link to AV
http://www.esoteric.msu.edu/VolumeVII/Schmitt.htm
These sorts of attacks indicate that you have hit the right nerve. You have pierced through the taboo, you have become a threat.
Being a threat is never to be feared, but welcomed, and worn as a badge of honor.
Kudos!
Lieberman sounds like a person you'd like to meet once.
Ben,
I am, like ptcruiser, going to write in defence of my associate and friend. I find the fact that you were treated as such a big disgrace. Thinking blog(ger)s are not The Daily KO's Kup of tea...
A poem or play will surface on this very incident in due time. I will consult my muse and see if it is possible to shift her schedule a bit and move this paritular event ahead of the slew of other pressing inspirations. Methinks she will certainly find it in her best interests to do so, but she can be rather stubborn at times. (TPM's muse gives Mark a sideways glance...)
Ben,
Sites like those are of no use at all.
Honesty and courage are what are necessary to rein in these monsters.
You won't find large quantities of either unless you go looking, and yet you seem to have found both with Tinoire.
Ben,
I am often fascinated by people throw dirty mud such as conspiracy theory at their opponents. Did you see a recent film the Children of Men? If no, I urge you to see it. Fascism is coming back and the target of the new forms of ethnic cleaning are going to be Arabs, Muslims and Africans. I am posting here a piece shocking piece from today’s Guardian which paints a grime future. The new fascism will come in response to the fear of haves against the have-nots; the haves willdo all sort of things to keep what have and gain more such as the use of superior technologies and high tech weapons.
In this sense, Lieberman is in good company; that is why his views are tolerated by the left for they too share his racist views. That is what there is massive silence in the face of genocides in your times.
Revolution, flashmobs, and brain chips. A grim vision of the future
Richard Norton-Taylor
Monday April 9, 2007
Guardian
Information chips implanted in the brain. Electromagnetic pulse weapons. The middle classes becoming revolutionary, taking on the role of Marx's proletariat. The population of countries in the Middle East increasing by 132%, while Europe's drops as fertility falls. "Flashmobs" - groups rapidly mobilised by criminal gangs or terrorists groups.
This is the world in 30 years' time envisaged by a Ministry of Defence team responsible for painting a picture of the "future strategic context" likely to face Britain's armed forces. It includes an "analysis of the key risks and shocks". Rear Admiral Chris Parry, head of the MoD's Development, Concepts & Doctrine Centre which drew up the report, describes the assessments as "probability-based, rather than predictive".
The 90-page report comments on widely discussed issues such as the growing economic importance of India and China, the militarisation of space, and even what it calls "declining news quality" with the rise of "internet-enabled, citizen-journalists" and pressure to release stories "at the expense of facts". It includes other, some frightening, some reassuring, potential developments that are not so often discussed.
New weapons
An electromagnetic pulse will probably become operational by 2035 able to destroy all communications systems in a selected area or be used against a "world city" such as an international business service hub. The development of neutron weapons which destroy living organs but not buildings "might make a weapon of choice for extreme ethnic cleansing in an increasingly populated world". The use of unmanned weapons platforms would enable the "application of lethal force without human intervention, raising consequential legal and ethical issues". The "explicit use" of chemical, biological, radiological, and nuclear weapons and devices delivered by unmanned vehicles or missiles.
Technology
By 2035, an implantable "information chip" could be wired directly to the brain. A growing pervasiveness of information communications technology will enable states, terrorists or criminals, to mobilise "flashmobs", challenging security forces to match this potential agility coupled with an ability to concentrate forces quickly in a small area.
Marxism
"The middle classes could become a revolutionary class, taking the role envisaged for the proletariat by Marx," says the report. The thesis is based on a growing gap between the middle classes and the super-rich on one hand and an urban under-class threatening social order: "The world's middle classes might unite, using access to knowledge, resources and skills to shape transnational processes in their own class interest". Marxism could also be revived, it says, because of global inequality. An increased trend towards moral relativism and pragmatic values will encourage people to seek the "sanctuary provided by more rigid belief systems, including religious orthodoxy and doctrinaire political ideologies, such as popularism and Marxism".
Pressures leading to social unrest
By 2010 more than 50% of the world's population will be living in urban rather than rural environments, leading to social deprivation and "new instability risks", and the growth of shanty towns. By 2035, that figure will rise to 60%. Migration will increase. Globalisation may lead to levels of international integration that effectively bring inter-state warfare to an end. But it may lead to "inter-communal conflict" - communities with shared interests transcending national boundaries and resorting to the use of violence.
Population and Resources
The global population is likely to grow to 8.5bn in 2035, with less developed countries accounting for 98% of that. Some 87% of people under the age of 25 live in the developing world. Demographic trends, which will exacerbate economic and social tensions, have serious implications for the environment - including the provision of clean water and other resources - and for international relations. The population of sub-Saharan Africa will increase over the period by 81%, and that of Middle Eastern countries by 132%.
The Middle East
The massive population growth will mean the Middle East, and to a lesser extent north Africa, will remain highly unstable, says the report. It singles out Saudi Arabia, the most lucrative market for British arms, with unemployment levels of 20% and a "youth bulge" in a state whose population has risen from 7 million to 27 million since 1980. "The expectations of growing numbers of young people [in the whole region] many of whom will be confronted by the prospect of endemic unemployment ... are unlikely to be met," says the report.
Islamic militancy
Resentment among young people in the face of unrepresentative regimes "will find outlets in political militancy, including radical political Islam whose concept of Umma, the global Islamic community, and resistance to capitalism may lie uneasily in an international system based on nation-states and global market forces", the report warns. The effects of such resentment will be expressed through the migration of youth populations and global communications, encouraging contacts between diaspora communities and their countries of origin.
Tension between the Islamic world and the west will remain, and may increasingly be targeted at China "whose new-found materialism, economic vibrancy, and institutionalised atheism, will be an anathema to orthodox Islam".
Iran
Iran will steadily grow in economic and demographic strength and its energy reserves and geographic location will give it substantial strategic leverage. However, its government could be transformed. "From the middle of the period," says the report, "the country, especially its high proportion of younger people, will want to benefit from increased access to globalisation and diversity, and it may be that Iran progressively, but unevenly, transforms...into a vibrant democracy."
Terrorism
Casualties and the amount of damage inflicted by terrorism will stay low compared to other forms of coercion and conflict. But acts of extreme violence, supported by elements within Islamist states, with media exploitation to maximise the impact of the "theatre of violence" will persist. A "terrorist coalition", the report says, including a wide range of reactionary and revolutionary rejectionists such as ultra-nationalists, religious groupings and even extreme environmentalists, might conduct a global campaign of greater intensity".
Climate change
There is "compelling evidence" to indicate that climate change is occurring and that the atmosphere will continue to warm at an unprecedented rate throughout the 21st century. It could lead to a reduction in north Atlantic salinity by increasing the freshwater runoff from the Arctic. This could affect the natural circulation of the north Atlantic by diminishing the warming effect of ocean currents on western Europe. "The drop in temperature might exceed that of the miniature ice age of the 17th and 18th centuries."
Guardian Unlimited © Guardian News and Media Limited 2007
http://www.guardian.co.uk/print/0,,329772274-117780,00.html
Ben,
Richard (http://rickwrites.blogspot.com), a british blogger, has left a comment on my latest post in which I mentioned your censoring at kos, relating his own experience at KOS. It is worth reading. It seems that the problem of censorship is wider and the blogosphere should revise its image of Kos as a 'liberal' website.
amina - I just saw children of men.
A must see. very real. considering the subject matter, I did not flinch once....
here's a great review
A lot in common with TS Eliot's the waste land:
burial of the dead
shantih shantih shantih - said throughout the movie and the last three lines of eliot's poem
The Waste Land
Jersey Cynic,
many thanks for your comment and the link to that marvelous review of Children of Men! I must say that I love Orson Welles’ Citizen Kane many more times than Casa Blanca for the latter glosses over the reality of French colonial rule of Algeria. Perhaps if Casa Blanca highlighted this contradiction, we might have been in the current mess in Iraq! In my view, Orson Welles is/was one greatest American literary/cinematic/theatrical figures, period.
Jersey Cynic,
I went to your blog but there is nothing there- it is just blank space. I guess you are busy like me!At any case, many more thanks for the wonderful URL links.
Jersey and amina,
I watched "Children of Men" last week and found it to be a sharp blade pressed against the jugular and quite a beautifully dark story.
Peace.
Mark, yours is the gift of words! No one could say it better than He, ThePoetryMan!
http://www.dark-wraith.com/
Ben - A superb editorial on your behalf from the Dark Wraith.
please read out there/here....
Censorship from the Left ~Dark Wraith
Hi Ben
I am not surprised about this story at all, because in time of struggles you can never allow yourself to be unprepared to anything.
I like all your work, cartoons, journalism, interviews.
And I am always on your side.
Ciao Mario
Kos desperately wants to be accepted by the Democratic mainstream, which is why he leaps at every opportunity to stifle truly liberal thought.
Thanks Amina for the last url
Diana, I think it was more than a nerve. I touched the brain. At least the Zionist part of the brain.
Amina, unfortunately, I didn't see Children of Men yet, but I will as soon as I can.
Thanks for pasting this brilliant article! I'll try to publish it on my Blog today!
Sophia, I'll have a look there : http://rickwrites.blogspot.com and read the comment you talk about.
I know there has been many censored people at DK... There even is a logo saying "Proud to have been banned by Daily Kos". Ha ha, this is too crazy!!
Mark, I thank your muse for the wonderful poem you came up with, about Freedom of expression and about the power of Art.
I'll be always grateful to you.
Jersey, many thanks for letting me know, I saw this brilliant editorial and I linked up with the Blog (Dark Wraith) owner.
Post a Comment